Exams are not the answer


Weekly Newsletter

Practical AI Strategies

Exams are not the answer

Hi everyone,

I admit I got a bit angry this week. The media coverage of AI in education has been hostile for a while now, and if you teach in Australia you've no doubt seen an increase in articles blaming schools and universities for "not doing enough" in the face of so-called AI cheating.

But I boiled over when I saw an article in The Age - a prominent Australian mainstream paper - criticising a Melbourne school for students apparently cheating en masse in an "English oral exam".

Many of you will know that I was an English teacher for fifteen years. For half of that time I was also an examiner. I can confidently tell you that there is no such thing as an oral exam in Victoria. The article conflated an item of coursework - which most schools require students to prepare for out of class - with an examination to make it more contentious and headline grabbing. "Students cheat in exam" is becoming just another throwaway term used by the media to insult educators.

We know better. We know that schools and universities are working hard to come to terms with AI. We know educators are trying to find ways to coexist with a technology that none of us asked for. And we know that media narratives like this will only lead to more exams and antagonism between teachers and students.

So I've started a two-part article writing about why exams are not the answer. This week, I focus on why the media narrative is harmful to more important conversations about assessment.

Practical AI for Curriculum Leaders: Term 3 Early Bird Access Closing

This weekend is the last opportunity to grab early bird access to the Term 3 cohort of Practical AI for Curriculum Leaders. The cohort is capped at 25 people and open to K-12, higher education, and vocational/adult education around the world.

For six weeks from July 21st we have live & recorded one-hour sessions structured around developing a strategy for curriculum leaders working with GenAI in their teams.

In Term 2 I was overwhelmed by the sharing of ideas and skills from educators in Australia, Canada, and elsewhere. For Term 3 we're already looking at a diverse and international mix of educators: come and join us in July!

Cheers,

Leon


Stay informed.
The Practical AI Library curates fresh, practical articles, research, and advice on AI and education—updated every week. Check it out
Check it out → Practical AI Library


211 Tahara Grassdale Road, Grassdale, VIC 3302
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Leon Furze

I'm a educator, writer, and podcaster who loves to talk about artificial intelligence, education, and writing & storytelling. Subscribe and join over 9,000+ educators every week!

Read more from Leon Furze

Weekly Newsletter Practical AI Strategies Exams are not the answer (part two) Hi everyone, There's a narrative in the media and amongst a lot of people I speak with: AI makes coursework easy to fake, exams are hard to fake, so schools should do more exams. It sounds like common sense, and it's wrong on two counts. First, it's bad pedagogy, which teachers already know, and second, it directly contradicts the assessment authorities that certify every Year 12 student in this country, which fewer...

Weekly Newsletter Practical AI Strategies If you know, you know: practice to principles Hi everyone, For the past few months I've been working on a series of posts called "if you know, you know", or IYKYK. The basic idea is that you can use GenAI in all kinds of weird and interesting ways, but only if you know what's already possible. That creates huge problems, because by design AI just looks a bit like a search engine. Because of this, most people's mental models of GenAI are "a thing...

Weekly Newsletter Practical AI Strategies AI and the Techlash Hi everyone, I'm sure you've noticed an uptick in articles recently which are not only anti-tech, but specifically anti-AI. For the past few years, I've been writing about the (many) ethical concerns of the AI industry: environmental concerns, bias, privacy, and more. But in recent months, there's been a new surge of mainstream media journalism about the technology. A lot of it has been positioned around the "cognitive offload"...